The New Yorker Pizza

Discover delicious New York-style pizza and flavorful dishes at The New Yorker Pizza in Petaluma, CA. Enjoy pesto twists, eggplant parmigiana, meatballs, and more in a lively atmosphere. Call +1 707-762-7595 today!

View MenuContact

Welcome to The New Yorker Pizza

Experience the finest dining

The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza

The New Yorker Pizza offers an authentic bite of New York right in Petaluma, CA. Located at 3 Petaluma Blvd N, this buzzing pizza joint serves delectable slices that transport taste buds straight to The Big Apple. Known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious dishes, it attracts locals and visitors alike. The menu caters to all pizza enthusiasts with options ranging from classic pies to specialty delights. Perfect for families, friends, or a casual date night, The New Yorker Pizza combines great food with good vibes, making every meal an enjoyable experience. Try the pesto twists or the signature eggplant parmesan for a truly special treat.

This restaurant showcases a wide variety of pizza options, including a build-your-own pizza experience. Diners can choose from different sizes—mini, 12", 14", or 16"—and customize their toppings. The specialty pizzas offer unique flavors like Mini Combo or Meat Pizza, sure to please every palate.

Side orders enhance the experience, featuring cheesy pesto twists and classic breadsticks. Customers rave about the meatball and chicken parmesan sandwiches, which serve as hearty meals perfect for any occasion.

With a diverse kids' menu and enticing desserts like cannoli, there's something for everyone.

Convenience is key here, as you can enjoy a slice on-the-go or dine in. Just a note, Saturday evenings at 6 PM are peak times, so planning a visit during off-peak hours, like weekday lunches, ensures a more relaxed dining experience.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

3 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952, United States

Phone

+1 707-762-7595

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza
The New Yorker Pizza

The New Yorker Pizza stands as a staple in Petaluma, drawing in pizza lovers and families for years. Locals celebrate this eatery not just for its culinary offerings but also for the palpable sense of community it fosters. The vibrant atmosphere takes shape through the laughter and conversations of guests enjoying their meals.

Each dish reflects the love and care of the kitchen team, committed to bringing authentic New York-style tastes. Fresh ingredients form the backbone of every pizza, ensuring that every slice satisfies.

Signature items like the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich and Eggplant Parmigiana shine through on the menu, making lunch and dinner here something special. With the average cost hovering around $15, it offers fantastic value without sacrificing quality. What's notable is the option for pizza by the slice, making it an ideal choice for those needing a quick yet delicious meal.

The restaurant's commitment to quality extends beyond the food. A friendly staff serves customers with a warm smile, creating an inviting environment that feels just like home.

The decor embodies a fun New York aesthetic, reminding diners of bustling city streets and iconic pizza joints. For those wanting a spirited dining experience, The New Yorker Pizza is the place to be.

The New Yorker Pizza

The New Yorker Pizza boasts an inviting exterior that encourages passersby to walk in and grab a slice. Located conveniently at 3 Petaluma Blvd N, its lively façade and outdoor seating create a welcoming vibe. Families gather, friends meet for casual chats, and foodies indulge in delightful pizza flavors under the afternoon sun.

On weekends, the breezy outdoor seating fills up with cheerful patrons eager to savor their freshly made orders. The vibrant spirit of Petaluma is mirrored in the bustling restaurant, promoting a sense of belonging for every guest.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

I ordered a pizza for my mother in Petaluma. She was having a bad day. Placed the order from Louisiana. She loved the pizza and the tarts that came with it. Looking at the pictures has made me really hungry. I'll have to visit the next time I'm in town. Well done.

G
Gary

If you like New York style pizza, this is it. It is the best pizza in Petaluma! Everything in a good bite of pizza should be balanced. The sauce shouldn't overpower the cheese and vice versa. The crust-to-sauce ratio should be even, and the choice of toppings should work fine together.. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful. The product quality is consistently outstanding, exceeding my expectations every time! I always order extra thin. They kick out of the park with its perfectly crispy, thin CRISP crust. I especially love their pizzas, but these last few times. My boyfriend and I have become a huge fan of their meatball and sausage penne pasta! The staff is also very friendly and accommodating.

B
Bianka C.

Had a great pizza here. Thin-ish good crust, I asked for extra crispy. Great cheese and sauce. The sausage is exceptional. Friendly staff.

C
Carl O.

ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT! We were trying to decide where to eat dinner while we visited Downtown Petaluma and parked right in front of the restaurant. We were so impressed with the home cooked meals we received, it has this welcome feeling and old fashioned atmosphere that is hard to find nowadays. We recommend it 100% and you can bet we're coming back again and bringing out acquaintances. Thank you New Yorker Pizza

R
Raymond L.

Great little place. I had linguine with garlic and clams and it was delicious. Definitely enough for two meals which I'm looking forward to eating tomorrow. The garlic bread is also very good

J
Joe G.

Great family pizza place. The space and 1st impressions are not very inspiring but the service and excellent food totally made up for it! Our kids loved their "mini" pizza and excellent spaghetti with meatballs.

V
V M.